Sunday, October 28, 2012

Cookie Butter Cups

Move over Reese's...

'Cause here come Cookie Butter Cups!

That's right, the deliciously addictive spread has now been turned even more deliciously addictive, by sandwiching it between rich dark chocolate.

I ate three straight from the freezer.  Whoops.  I couldn't help myself.  These cups are just so yummy.  

Seriously, they blast Reese's right out of the water.  Soon, kids will be asking for these instead of the famous peanut butter cups on Halloween night.

Which is actually totally fine, because, unlike most popular candies on the market, these treats are made with only 5 ingredients, all of which are pronounceble.  So you see, it's a win, win.  Better nutrition, better taste.

Do yourself a favor and, whether you want to be the person to introduce Cookie Butter Cups to the world or just want to try the delicious-ness I'm raving about, get a little bit ahead of the game and throw together these delightful little treats for Halloween this year.  I swear they'll be gone in an instant.

Chocolate Cookie Butter Cups
(makes 10 mini cups)

  • 1/4 cup cocoa powder
  • 1/4 cup coconut oil, melted
  • 2 tbsp maple syrup (you can add more of you have a sweet tooth)
  • 1/2 banana
  • 1-2 tbsp speculoos cookie butter
Combine first 3 ingredients in a small bowl and stir until it turns into a smooth chocolate sauce.  Pour a thin layer into mini cupcake liners (or regular cupcake liners, or molds), making sure to leave some of the sauce for later.  Freeze cupcake liners for 10 minutes, or until chocolate has hardened.  Meanwhile, microwave the banana and cookie butte together in a small bowl until easily stirred.  Mix well.  Put a blob of cookie butter micture on top of chocolate layer in each mini cupcake liner, and cover with another thin layer of chocolate sauce.  Freeze again until hard.  Then, store in freezer or fridge until serving time (personaly, I like them more straight from the freezer).

Wow, writing this post really made me want to eat more of these.  I'm off to go grab the last one... and then most likely make more.  Oh my are they delicious.

Just a few more notes before I go off to devour a Cookie Butter Cup:
  • Speculoos Cookie Butter is, in fact, vegan.  Meaning that these Cookie Butter Cups are vegan as well.  Vegans, rejoice!
  • For the super easy version of this recipe, just melt down some of your favorite chocolate (i recommend good quality dark chocolate), and use that instead of the coconut oil chocolate sauce
  • For a lower calorie version of this recipe, you could try substituting stevia for the maple syrup.  I haven't tried this, however, and am not sure about how the taste would be or what amount would be best to use.
Without further ado, I send you off to your kitchen to mix up some of this utter yumminess.  


Revisited Recipe of the Day:

Pin It!


  1. I've made a few chocolates with coconut oil before. Cool idea to fill it with banana. Sounds delicious :)

    1. I love making chocolate with coconut oil. Makes it so rich and delicious.

      And don't forget the Speculoos in the filling. It totally makes the recipe 10x better.

  2. Oooh, that looks so amazing! What a cool idea.

  3. Trader joes cookie butter has wheat in are you sure these are gluten free?

    1. I know that now. Silly me had a stupid moment and forgot about the "cookies" in "Cookie" butter.

  4. 3 Studies SHOW How Coconut Oil Kills Waist Fat.

    The meaning of this is that you literally get rid of fat by eating Coconut Fats (in addition to coconut milk, coconut cream and coconut oil).

    These 3 researches from major medicinal magazines are sure to turn the traditional nutrition world around!